Sunday 31 March 2019

Log #131 - A Cluster Of Faustian Harmonia

Eddy Bamyasi

I've considered myself a relatively knowledgeable fan of Krautrock for many years - ever since I stumbled across my first Can album in a second hand store in Chichester one school lunch hour nearly 40 years ago (it was the spanner in the sky one which was how it was known, or aka simply Can, or Inner Space) (it was an interesting record pretty unlike anything else I had in my collection at the time (I was unaccustomed to the monotonic singing, the fluttery jazzy drumming and the in-your-face synths) but my life didn't really change until I heard Tago Mago a few months later from whence I was launched into Krautrock space: My rocket ship taking me to planets Neu! Grobschnitt, Kraftwerk, Tangerine Dream, Nektar, and Klaus Schulze).

The caveat being of course that the much maligned (including by the artists themselves) term Krautrock has varied and wide meanings. For me I think it covers a particular genre of rock music that was coming out of Germany in the early to mid 70s. This is music characterised by repetitive "motorik" beats - it certainly wasn't the blues based rock or progrock prevalent in the UK and US at the time although there was a small degree of overlap. It wasn't all the German rock music either - I don't think a band like Scorpions is a Krautrock band for instance.

It is also arguable whether the synth bands like Kraftwerk and Tangerine Dream were really Krautrock. Their music is more often associated with the terms Kosmische (cosmic) or Berlin School (although the latter term didn't gain much traction until Eno and Bowie, heavily influenced by German electronic music, rocked up in that city in the mid 70s).

The origins of the more generic term Krautrock are disputed but seem to derive from use by some music journalists and radio DJ John Peel was an early adopter in the early 70s. German band Faust even recorded a track entitled Krautrock as early as 1974 but would later, like most of their contemporaries, distance themselves from the term explaining that "when the English people started talking about Krautrock, we thought they were just taking the piss".  Nevertheless the term gained more credence especially as the bands became retrospectively influential and revered reaching a critical mass through Julian Cope's legendary 1995 Krautrocksampler book. Cope would explain though that the term was merely a subjective British word based on the way the music was received in the UK rather than on the actual West German music scene out of which it grew.

The point of the lengthy preamble is new (to me) Krautrock music is still coming to my ears for the first time pretty much proving I was not as knowledgeable or well-listened (well-listened should be a word too like well-read) on the subject as I had thought. This week I've been enjoying a diet of Faust, Cluster, Popul Vuh and Harmonia. All bands I've not studied before. In coming weeks I'll delve deeper into Krautrock outer space and hope to take trips to Planets Ash Ra Tempel, Guru Guru, and Amon Duul.

This week's selection in the magazine centres on a family of overlapping artists - personnel was shared throughout the bands Neu!, Harmonia and Cluster (also called Kluster and Qluster at different times).

The Neu!/Harmonia/Cluster cast list:

Klaus Dinger - Kraftwerk, Neu!, La Dusseldorf
Michael Rother - Kraftwerk, Neu!, Cluster
Hans-Joachim Roedelius - Kluster, Cluster, Harmonia, Qluster
Dieter Moebius - Cluster, Harmonia
Conny Plank - producer for Can, Harmonia, Cluster, Kraftwerk, Scorpions
Brian Eno - Cluster, Harmonia

The world's most important rock band.

Did Brian Eno really say that about the short lived collaboration of Cluster and Neu! musicians otherwise known as Harmonia? It is indeed a crying shame the band were so short lived and produced only 3 albums as they sound excellent. In fact one of the best Krautrock bands I've come across.

Their first two albums Music Von Harmonia and Deluxe are both superb - containing a hybrid mix of beats and ambience / a sort of half way house between the electro synth styles of Tangerine Dream say, and the rock of Neu!. The synth pads are thick and bassy like the sound on Kraftwerk's Autobahn. The rhythms are hypnotic and ravey. Watussi and Walky Talky are orgasmic tunes. The third album Tracks and Traces featured Eno (forming a bona fide "supergroup") and had an unaccountably delayed release of some 20 years eventually seeing the light of day in 1997. This one is a little more ambient.

Not surprisingly Cluster are similarly excellent. Across a much longer lifespan (13 albums) they started off experimental, before moving more into the mainstream of motorik beat led Krautrock, and then ambience. Zuckerzeit and Sowiesoso both from the mid 70s tend to be the go-to albums for the group.

Last in the Krautrock series this week is Faust and their classic IV album. I like the cover which with its empty music staves takes minimalism to an extreme. I get the impression Faust didn't take their art too seriously. The album is much more psychedelic heavy rock (even punky) than most Krautrock. The distorted guitars and synth effects remind me very much of Hawkwind. There's whimsy with an amateur sounding The Sad Skinhead:

Apart from all the bad times you gave me
I always felt good with you
Going places, smashing faces
what else could we do?

... and the Gong/Zappa like Giggy Smile with its jaunty singing and saxophone breaks. This track sounds very familiar. It is either very similar to something else or I've heard this track before never knowing it was Faust.

The best tracks are more traditionally Krautrock like Jennifer which for the first half is Ege Bamyasi style rumbling bass and distant vocals before it descends into weirdness (in this case massive noise and saloon piano). Lauft... is another song of two halves. The first half is 60s Love-like acoustic guitar, and the second half consists of a slow organ solo. Final track maintains the 60s feel with a Syd Barrett like song interspersed with rude blasts of distorted organ and guitar.

Not much time for the other albums this week (but note the Father John Misty is brilliant - a cross between Elton John and John Grant and certainly one to watch) but for the record they are:


Band Of Horses Infinite Arms  
Harmonia Deluxe
Faust IV
Father John Misty God's Favourite Customer
Cluster Zuckerzeit
Pink Floyd Atom Heart Mother








About The Author

Eddy Bamyasi

Eddy is a music writer from Brighton, England, named after a Can record. Each Sunday he logs and reviews the albums that happen to be in his vintage Pioneer 6-CD magazine changer, amongst other things.

3 comments:

  1. Nice one Eddy. I'd highly recommend the first Cluster & Eno album - extremely pretty and delveworthy. (And what sounds suspiciously like Robert Fripp playing guitar on 'Steinsame'.)

    You touched on Popol Vuh so it'd be remiss of me not to mention 'In den Gärten Pharaos' (PV 2nd album) particularly for the stunning near-religious experience that is 'Vuh'. First album is also out there, but in a slightly more improv'd (ie synths and bongos) manner. PS. Florian Fricke must have been independently wealthy as he was the first person to own a modular Moog in Germany at the time. He ditched the Moog on his 3rd album (bah!) but sold it to Klaus Schulze (wahey!)

    ReplyDelete
  2. P.S. Love the use of 'well-listened'. Excellent!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for the comments and tips Peter Cat. Coincidentally another reader has just alerted me to In The Garden...too, and it will form the centrepiece of this week's blog entry. Fascinating these artists at the dawn of the invention of the moog and synthesizer, creating these revolutionary sounds.

    ReplyDelete

Powered by Blogger.

Leading Artists (by appearance)

neil young (26) van morrison (22) john martyn (18) tangerine dream (18) felice brothers (16) pink floyd (14) led zeppelin (13) black sabbath (12) brian eno (12) whitest boy alive (12) bonnie prince billy (11) can (11) david sylvian (11) radiohead (11) talk talk (11) beatles (10) cluster (10) cocteau twins (10) laura marling (10) nick cave (10) afro celts (9) beck (9) bob dylan (9) fennesz (9) genesis (9) iron and wine (8) loscil (8) midlake (8) paolo nutini (8) tom waits (8) autechre (7) foals (7) nucleus (7) richard hawley (7) stars of the lid (7) camel (6) david bowie (6) dj vadim (6) efterklang (6) elo (6) fairport convention (6) harmonia (6) holger czukay (6) kings of convenience (6) low (6) luke vibert (6) matthew e white (6) miles davis (6) sahb (6) the doobie brothers (6) tord gustavsen (6) war on drugs (6) william basinski (6) arovane (5) bear's den (5) black keys (5) boards of canada (5) bob marley (5) calexico (5) edgar froese (5) father john misty (5) hawkwind (5) jan jelinek (5) king crimson (5) mouse on mars (5) nils frahm (5) public service broadcasting (5) robert plant (5) sigur ros (5) takemitsu (5) arbouretum (4) badly drawn boy (4) budgie (4) carly simon (4) carole king (4) decemberists (4) emeralds (4) four tet (4) handsome family (4) hidden orchestra (4) jethro tull (4) jj cale (4) john legend (4) klaus schulze (4) kruder and dorfmeister (4) manuel gottsching (4) opeth (4) penguin cafe orchestra (4) ravi shankar (4) soft hair (4) steely dan (4) the unthanks (4) tim hecker (4) trees (4) ulrich schnauss (4) KLF (3) alan parsons project (3) alex harvey (3) alison krauss (3) alva noto (3) barclay james harvest (3) bon iver (3) bonobo (3) caitlin canty (3) caribou (3) chicago (3) coldplay (3) curtis mayfield (3) david crosby (3) deep purple (3) depeche mode (3) eilen jewell (3) enid (3) fleetwood mac (3) floating points (3) free (3) gorillaz (3) gram parsons (3) grateful dead (3) grobschnitt (3) incredible string band (3) james morrison (3) jill scott (3) john grant (3) john surman (3) keith jarrett (3) kraftwerk (3) lal waterson (3) last shadow puppets (3) lift to experience (3) lynyrd skynyrd (3) mahavishnu orchestra (3) manitoba (3) mike oldfield (3) mike waterson (3) monolake (3) neu! (3) palace brothers (3) philip glass (3) popol vuh (3) quantic (3) rodriguez (3) rokia traore (3) rolling stones (3) rory gallagher (3) roxy music (3) rush (3) simon and garfunkel (3) sly and the family stone (3) steve hillage (3) suede (3) sufjan stevens (3) the comet is coming (3) tim buckley (3) wagon christ (3) wilco (3) 4hero (2) abc (2) ac/dc (2) al stewart (2) amon duul II (2) aphex twin (2) arctic monkeys (2) baka beyond (2) band of horses (2) belle and sebastian (2) blue oyster cult (2) blue states (2) bonzo dog band (2) boris salchow (2) burial (2) cardigans (2) carlos barbosa-lima (2) charles mingus (2) chemical brothers (2) chris rea (2) cinematic orchestra (2) compilations (2) crosby stills nash (2) david darling (2) death in vegas (2) debussy (2) dj shadow (2) doors (2) earl sweatshirt (2) eloy (2) emilie simon (2) erik satie (2) farben (2) festivals (2) fleet foxes (2) francois and the atlas mountains (2) fripp and eno (2) gas (2) gong (2) granados (2) green on red (2) griffin anthony (2) jazzland (2) jean sibelius (2) jeff buckley (2) john coltrane (2) johnny flynn (2) josh t pearson (2) julian cope (2) kamasi washington (2) kanye west (2) kate bush (2) ketil bjornstad (2) la dusseldorf (2) lambchop (2) larkin poe (2) little feat (2) ludovico einaudi (2) magma (2) marianne faithfull (2) marvin gaye (2) mike lazarev (2) money mark (2) morton feldman (2) nektar (2) nightmares on wax (2) ninja (2) nirvana (2) nitin sawhney (2) peace (2) porya hatami (2) prefuse 73 (2) prem joshua (2) randy newman (2) robert fripp (2) ryan adams (2) scorpions (2) scott and maria (2) scott matthews (2) servants of science (2) soft machine (2) steve miller (2) susumu yokota (2) talvin singh (2) the who (2) thievery corporation (2) traffic (2) truckstop honeymoon (2) ufo (2) up bustle and out (2) weather report (2) wiley (2) willard grant conspiracy (2) wishbone ash (2) wyclef jean (2) yes (2) abba (1) acid mothers temple and the cosmic inferno (1) aimee mann (1) air (1) alabama 3 (1) alice coltrane (1) amadou and mariam (1) andy shauf (1) anthony hamilton (1) april wine (1) arcade fire (1) ashra (1) asia (1) badger (1) barber (1) beach boys (1) bee gees (1) beirut (1) bert jansch (1) beuno vista social club (1) bill laswell (1) biosphere (1) bjork (1) blow monkeys (1) bob geldof (1) bob holroyd (1) bob seger (1) bombay bicycle club (1) boubacar traore (1) broken social scene (1) bruce springsteen (1) bruch (1) byline (1) captain beefheart (1) cardi b (1) cast (1) cat stevens (1) catfish and the bottlemen (1) charles and eddie (1) chopin (1) chris child (1) christine and the queens (1) chuck prophet (1) climax blues band (1) cosmic jokers (1) crowded house (1) d'angelo (1) daft punk (1) david goodrich (1) davy graham (1) dexy's midnight runners (1) dolly collins (1) donald fagen (1) dreadzone (1) dub pistols (1) eagles (1) echo and the bunnymen (1) eden espinosa (1) eels (1) elbow (1) electric ape (1) emerson lake and palmer (1) erlend oye (1) erukah badu (1) essays (1) euphony in electronics (1) faust (1) feist (1) flaming lips (1) future days (1) gamma (1) gang of four (1) gentle giant (1) goat roper rodeo band (1) godspeed you black emperor (1) gorecki (1) groove armada (1) grover washington jr. (1) gun (1) guru guru (1) hatfield and the north (1) hats off gentlemen it's adequate (1) heron (1) hiss golden messenger (1) hozier (1) human league (1) idles (1) india arie (1) iron and wire (1) isaac hayes (1) james brown (1) james joys (1) jamie t (1) janelle monae (1) jayhawks (1) jean-michel jarre (1) jerry paper (1) jim croce (1) jimi hendrix (1) jjcale (1) john cale (1) john mclaughlin (1) jon hassell (1) jurassic 5 (1) kacey musgraves (1) keith berry (1) kid loco (1) king tubby (1) king's consort (1) kings of leon (1) kirk degiorgio (1) kodomo (1) lenny kravitz (1) lighthouse (1) love supreme (1) luc vanlaere (1) lumineers (1) mark pritchard (1) mark ronson (1) me'shell ndegeocello (1) messiaen (1) metallica (1) micah frank (1) michael hedges (1) michael jackson (1) mike west (1) mitski (1) modest mouse (1) moody blues (1) morte macabre (1) motorhead (1) national health (1) nick drake (1) nusrat fateh ali khan (1) oasis (1) omd (1) orb (1) orquesta reve (1) other lives (1) oval (1) paco pena (1) paladin (1) panda bear (1) pat metheny (1) paulo nutini (1) pentangle (1) pierre bensusan (1) portishead (1) proprio (1) protoje (1) purcell (1) pussy riot (1) queen (1) rainbow (1) ramsay midwood (1) rautavaara (1) rem (1) rhythm kings (1) richard strauss (1) robyn (1) roni size (1) ryuichi sakamoto (1) sada sat kaur (1) saga (1) sam jordan (1) sammy hagar (1) santana (1) scaramanga silk (1) shakti (1) shirley collins (1) shostakovich (1) snafu (1) snatam kaur (1) sparks (1) st germain (1) stanford (1) steeleye span (1) stereolab (1) steve reich (1) styx (1) supertramp (1) susumo yokota (1) t bone walker (1) terry riley (1) the band (1) the clash (1) the jayhawks (1) the streets (1) the wreks (1) tricky (1) tycho (1) uriah heep (1) velvet underground (1) venetian snares (1) vladislav delay (1) whiskeytown (1) whitesnake (1) william ackerman (1) yngwie j malmsteen (1) zhou yu (1) μ-Ziq (1)